We see a lot of “creative” roof repairs. But seeing metal panels used to patch an old shingle roof... that was a new one. It’s the perfect example of a 'quick fix' that’s likely to fail.
For commercial building owners, dealing with a leak can feel urgent. The temptation to opt for a quick fix is understandable—especially when downtime, safety, or operational continuity is at risk.
But patching with materials that don't belong together—like metal on shingles—is like using duct tape on a car engine. It doesn't just fail; it often makes things worse, giving water brand-new places to sneak in and damaging the roof's core.
What appears to be a temporary fix can develop into a long-term problem, financially and structurally.
Our Philosophy: The "No-Judgment" Zone
When our team faces a situation like this, we’re not here to judge. The client was simply trying to solve a problem. Our role is to provide clarity, guidance, and a lasting solution.
At Seamless Roofing, our philosophy is simple. As Eric Howland, Partner – Operations, put it in a recent LinkedIn post: We don’t judge—we inspect, inform, and partner.
We Inspect
The first step is a thorough assessment. That means looking past the surface-level “repair” to understand the real problem.
We examine:
- The roof’s underlying structure and condition
- The extent of water damage and potential leaks
- How prior repairs impact the longevity of any new solution
This thorough approach means we’re not just covering a visible issue. We’re addressing the root cause.
We Inform
Transparency is essential. We share our findings openly, often including photos and detailed explanations. For example, in this case, we clearly showed the client why metal panels over shingles were failing and why additional patchwork wouldn’t fix the issue.
Our clients can see the results of a hurried patch: gaps, mismatched materials, and possible water infiltration points. Providing this clarity helps them make better decisions about their property.
We Partner
Finally, we work with property owners to find an appropriate solution for their assets. A quick fix might seem easy, but it often costs more in the long run. Partnering involves discussing practical, long-term options—ones that balance performance, durability, aesthetics, and budget.
For this building, the conclusion was clear: another patch wouldn’t suffice.
The Right Solution: The "After"
The most effective solution was to get it right the first time with a professional, durable system built to last.
We are replacing the old, failing roof with a new metal system. This approach tackles the root problems and prevents recurring issues caused by incompatible materials.
As Eric Howland explains, the new roof will not only "look good," but more importantly, it will "keep the folks working here dry long into the future." The outcome provides the peace of mind that every building owner seeks: a reliable, long-lasting roof that protects employees, equipment, and operations.
A proper metal system offers:
- Durability – Metal roofs are designed to withstand extreme weather, reducing maintenance and repair costs.
- Waterproofing – Correct installation eliminates leaks caused by patchwork solutions.
- Longevity – A professionally installed metal roof can last decades, providing a significant return on investment.
- Energy efficiency – Reflective coatings and materials help control building temperatures, reducing energy consumption.
- Aesthetics – Clean, uniform panels enhance curb appeal and property value.
Choosing the right solution helps the client avoid recurring costs, reduce operational disruptions, and ensure the roof functions as intended.
The Real Cost of a 'Quick Fix'
Quick fixes may seem handy initially, but in roofing, they seldom last long. If you’re dealing with a leak, a patched roof, or any “creative” repair, it’s best to choose a solution built for performance, durability, and peace of mind.
Are you tired of repairs that don't last? Stop patching and start protecting. Contact Seamless Roofing for a diagnostic assessment. We can inspect your roof, clearly explain the issues, plan for potential problems, and partner with you to develop a long-term solution that safeguards your investment.